From d01515e755a4094deef06b4e2c4295a9cf4f1c40 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Evgeny Poberezkin Date: Sat, 1 Jun 2024 21:47:38 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] blog: Protecting Children's Safety Requires End-to-End Encryption --- ...children-safety-requires-e2e-encryption.md | 32 ++++++++++++++++++ blog/README.md | 6 ++++ blog/images/20240601-eu-privacy.png | Bin 0 -> 17508 bytes .../src/_includes/blog_previews/20240601.html | 2 ++ 4 files changed, 40 insertions(+) create mode 100644 blog/20240601-protecting-children-safety-requires-e2e-encryption.md create mode 100644 blog/images/20240601-eu-privacy.png create mode 100644 website/src/_includes/blog_previews/20240601.html diff --git a/blog/20240601-protecting-children-safety-requires-e2e-encryption.md b/blog/20240601-protecting-children-safety-requires-e2e-encryption.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..39a047f93f --- /dev/null +++ b/blog/20240601-protecting-children-safety-requires-e2e-encryption.md @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +--- +layout: layouts/article.html +title: "Protecting Children's Safety Requires End-to-End Encryption" +date: 2024-06-01 +previewBody: blog_previews/20240601.html +image: images/20240601-eu-privacy.png +permalink: "/blog/20240601-protecting-children-safety-requires-e2e-encryption.html" +--- + +# Protecting Children's Safety Requires End-to-End Encryption + +As lawmakers grapple with the serious issue of child exploitation online, some proposed solutions would fuel the very problem they aim to solve. Despite expert warnings, the Belgian Presidency persists in pushing for the implementation of client-side scanning on encrypted messaging services, rebranding the effort as "upload moderation". Their [latest proposal](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=COM%3A2022%3A209%3AFIN&qid=1652451192472) mandates that providers of private communication services obtain user consent for AI-based scanning of their private chats. If users do not consent, they will be prohibited from sharing images, videos, and URLs. + +Privacy critics have long pushed for measures like centralized scanning of private photos and messaging data, arguing it could detect illicit content. However, invasive monitoring of private communications would create detrimental risks that far outweigh any perceived benefits. + +## Why we’re taking action + +SimpleX Chat signed a [joint statement](https://www.globalencryption.org/2024/05/joint-statement-on-the-dangers-of-the-may-2024-council-of-the-eu-compromise-proposal-on-eu-csam/) about the dangers of the EU compromise proposal on EU CSAM because maintaining end-to-end encryption is crucial for protecting privacy and security for everyone, including and especially children.  + +We urge the Ministers in the Council of the EU to stand firm against any scanning proposals that undermine end-to-end encryption, which would enable mass surveillance and misuse by bad actors, whether framed as client-side scanning, upload moderation, or any other terminology. Compromising this basic principle opens the door to devastating privacy violations. We also urge any organizations or individuals reading this to write to their representatives and voice their concerns. European Digital Rights has [outlined these issues](https://edri.org/our-work/be-scanned-or-get-banned/) in greater detail for anyone seeking more information. + +## Why compromising privacy endangers children + +The core issue is that compromising encryption and privacy makes innocent people vulnerable to malicious hackers and criminals seeking to exploit users data. Centralized scanning systems become a tempting target, potentially exposing millions of private family photos when breached. This would easily open up avenues for blackmail, abuse, and victimization of children. A case in point is the recent [criminal charges](https://techcrunch.com/2024/01/17/unredacted-meta-documents-reveal-historical-reluctance-to-protect-children-new-mexico-lawsuit/) against Meta in New Mexico, which highlights how the tech giant's algorithms enabled child exploitation by encouraging connections between minors and sexual predators. Privacy-eroding initiatives like client-side scanning would play into the hands of malicious actors by making more sensitive information accessible and weaponized in the same way that it has been on Meta platforms. + +## What should be done + +Rather than undermining privacy, to achieve child safety online users should be empowered with high standards for encryption and data control. For example, adopting a model where children (and users in general) cannot be discovered or approached on networks unless they or their parents permit it, similar to the SimpleX network privacy model. Intelligent multi-device synchronization could enable this oversight without compromising end-to-end encryption overall. It’s always possible to protect children without opening everyone, especially children themselves, to greater vulnerabilities due to such proposals. + +However, some recent legislative efforts have bizarrely moved in the opposite direction by seeking to limit parental access. The chilling truth is that the least private platforms have been major enablers of child exploitation. Eroding privacy protections on other services will only aid criminals further, not protect children. Preserving strong encryption and user privacy must be the foundation for any credible effort to combat online child exploitation. Initiatives trading privacy for supposed safety are not just technically flawed, but would achieve the exact opposite of their stated intent. We must avoid being gaslighted by narratives that defy logic, and instead provide users with the highest possible standards for privacy protections as a core principle. + +Protecting end-to-end encryption without carving out backdoors or vulnerabilities should be non-negotiable for children's and everyone’s safety. It is critical to redirect the discourse to focus on taking genuine privacy further by protecting against [metadata hoarding](https://simplex.chat/blog/20240416-dangers-of-metadata-in-messengers.html) and other means by which people’s data can be abused or subjected to surveillance. diff --git a/blog/README.md b/blog/README.md index a5f3d60b2e..a040833712 100644 --- a/blog/README.md +++ b/blog/README.md @@ -1,5 +1,11 @@ # Blog +Jun 1, 2024 [Children's Safety Requires End-to-End Encryption](./20240601-children-safety-requires-e2e-encryption.md) + +As lawmakers grapple with the serious issue of child exploitation online, some proposed solutions would fuel the very problem they aim to solve. + +--- + May 16, 2024 [SimpleX: Redefining Privacy by Making Hard Choices](./20240516-simplex-redefining-privacy-hard-choices.md) When it comes to open source privacy tools, the status quo often dictates the limitations of existing protocols and structures. However, these norms need to be challenged to radically shift how we approach genuinely private communication. This requires doing some uncomfortable things, like making hard choices as it relates to funding, alternative decentralization models, doubling down on privacy over convenience, and more. diff --git a/blog/images/20240601-eu-privacy.png b/blog/images/20240601-eu-privacy.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..4ae1a17e30ba5b43e0fc6f39a84d23ac4b5737b6 GIT binary patch literal 17508 zcmeIa2T)Yc_AWY%gCdB6fCLGH2ufChNRlB5NRXU{U?6A7Q5Z5JSwJ!pB!lD}6p@^f zoRmBxIp^Cbp7VS6|6aYiw{F#~``*Elncm&Kckk}iYklims|k>olfcKNz=c2{_)?N$ ziVz4?7y`lC!np{p@L~3Mzz57wSQcC?48c2kjt$E2my(LI5QsAa1mfWhfgFHK9*Yo& z-8~2d{S5Sa4}p+c#aAf^fC>wJbtwZ`SqKyOjst;WU58u%->|?xh@UY8_WL^o0`3HU zVBx-yOW^Z5_^*|W_3xI+(7!FA!pRr@e#hE6>m;lsDkTLzm0nuw>s#0uS=x4F#V>=` zFf~?Iw^f&w;d^Om&h}i-@`XN|qq)^t7l?o(ANXpnZ~GkXXl`avs!2@cryE z`z`qICbp)6x720j;i8t-`tS#A_t@^;dV~vy!v(DM4EPkq9-nsyCBa)pwzgJ$?CcH> z4r~sbY?juB?Du(jdD-uAuyb&*f)=bcP8PP$9a$}G=>FW~?|sDdZC+X%TiF_0TENfl z`}~Eaovq-lTW1gY*Uz7E>N^_$`$-ly=dT4`ko~NN{XW}0_W!$Xw#Ekk58cjc{&f5O zUVk1ZaCS33d1FU?Gj%azb1@|ds)sq z|FiPH@A&(X8vl6YeU5)V@*g$-eNRzKGfQhFtLHEEAKgFi@{ddZXnpp=d{3>7!PuUk z&G=dK|8niTy#V{!a{Oa?{;d7)t6=dT;R>+-OOPJnF7oy%K_Cc-l$fxxBi8c7rFi1G z5vF6FOI^tx2!N$1$Zicu*X;2L$|j_8!6A zcp&XSh=5?h2oMldD1_FZ9eQ3(#)!b-upVCGIxiD=?p^)U&%+}O>J6v!OOT`ceIF0d zZT0MiXQlsi`!f^&r%#EV@U+ac^(yTmL-(xWAi;5y-cju$XN=CZUBq{=(jGC;TI5hv zmD5Na#N}ov{5WgOE4}!Gy>0aCOvK1Qw$J(Mf>ReWn3n8?UGoMqJ&dbwU z9t5-F!K~-9i+G7868gQ`Xito-+;gdT?+YlF0dXppt%iynb;q} z#|py65vI6CEh}+eUI5J(?9Bqsg_;77z>|wwAU62C+y$C>u*pVeio>V@Jr@`q=u?R()s?hp;P(It6_OTMS%r#g(Gk_KEr!p zFd1T__qul@4&2z>G+B5G54XtwueD@TZXfkjnIkXP)^Y#W+PjO~bOXy!kB$Kb@tGJzO3qsLTiYJ$=N(% z5&4V%+TZT;3E~$f!mITMm?0#n|iu`D5SvC4%a(zMsLKK(+U$4gzgp!Y+ zY3;7w<}Vg|tl^-S#b4Z4cvO;?c%^<<(`mY&FxWv&Ih;}LWPywPv`2q1EPXT>BW2&X zc4cr0H>kBNWCP53A`lKiX%mr#Xy^}`ZOuU{4RlwoE$g9l(X0b|BBS9WH`K3DUBRpg zwy|-^;JO9p%1y8PDRRZ>rc0B0rM4y&Y$g2jY)_*34uz+CE)#fOO%QZ>++c%>$0Ic3`j`3w}J9wPmH;*?mKRmO1#ouS{nV-{TIt|#w62Ju9;y@O`Ojcl)`r>$IZyT z{F943IT>s)g0&bhGQ$fZHUw5m&-9`z6*&#v)1GY4?yz85mzQ+Pesx8-GKY?66y+*8 zj0x5R<`q5oN`1^r{GqUDXPq31Q^5?Z@leDl!CEBZSBUd*O@g)Zp^vfUOu(R+KYGxH zzr8_KI(_6ha+%n!R3^^(X8O~>jZNaFgUTvVCQ%4V6j*bBGV%C_q& z?Xs8BZC0{Ne))bGwI1YL$e{EXko&g%USHc!S<%9shHZ(W%G9iLr)uNZTj7nZn0|e+ z3@?ZLte&(l{ZSM9b7j&yL9zOp6FR5Y+H*v`wp%TznNAO%TLv6t6wQ@7xy|Of$Lnek zJ`#ms(coI~b@+LSL=a@kJnM>$;;60o?9J*Xq1bAn%@U&g1-#b(K90=1K zmkVi1#9a-XNKf6}|Guk{v3hkprGP=6^3~~gj{SPZJ-`&5c}>#^!0*B zxJLsmv7`Mw979M_-ttz(T*;)VEe~IB&uz&2b&s@me7uz&scDo6<{(|IewFU{qg>R} zTwV_*q)yTh^5UeE&EhBpNusj9wT;seCRJ3TcRtrRQn3^r21ob8(V67HMOp+B-{m>|`&dX@uEoQiL^g=^oNW9rLj@8|9-9jK zIibn~>He}PZj`CM{4VnKVS%oO&cxh@e(J)Nlrfb#`|3QUP|_N!vP|+%8elV#K`Afe zetX!52NQu7bg#1F4e^wwD^&2PQ6IQgE@(96S62Ozs8Lz z7uWjDB~9-1}>x`}E05j{#zSOZ}RU zh6^Po)Tf)b2uJ4i^A@&yCr+upZ@E_{6FSwrsW^m})k-u+>D&f#tl%~nIb8+Jg z8q@-O=^R9wCl1f|sIrkt_!v`OCT?^KL1LQ{vh&qqt7#*+&$2CVW4wb-)CQNTzc;t~ z>p-LOVTn5JD*Flpu##m4B`Y_jiJf#A$Tu8JnXpvkIvuH2OJ1hkV+ZJ%8H+)Bz@);6 z1-g!n>)aJ;O!GGEW*!~lFjtCTnPqHu@LhjWRg1H{2|M|ByWpBb(QEv1*eM;C1r6J{ z3y!ru)(JhZ&F+!Q7?2rk)(p8(`PDh4#<>Dx*v>aH@|FXv=9v>0a>?%_?K8FMeGQ2> z&dC`ObFG%XPmcHb6U?%gA3Sw+d$-)|DCVH3jpSZ#>`j?he<2LPI>vrT_3@Of?*feS zQu4ioi3Mk$cFYOS_Y*$+_^RsO*Dy~81P<<~e;*AijPHTg9l!6xdE!Xpv~sA4@9Gsx z2jOL)To4`v?;yV4aU29HXn z(a#^~7-1J$-He>oBcTHu%lOPqAdjD*y;nA7*4lA5l5db(Sfcb0i@*yTH`lN{D_y5E zf#Vx)6AKun4nT;`wIes7gT|j?2z_2D6wom{J@@wD!+ltG=nz(y_-MMn#Z(9Gfp7-W zu=L7+9mgAHT^y(fkRlz$Otp=+Jgo5(X(NBvH7fio4lZx)yyd9~!6c%#0N&^`>`WvG zO|px><22ax=|{TxaZq3CQuZ41gyJ^ABa#~{)^Y}~7DtoUTuuPa-34CqYS739C?U$x z!Mh1bI^sc!BF>CbU_kd$6}B&p)8CN(;sO&O0f4nldJcz@xaHI9y>Cst$4!idUXMT4 zQ0U2q4yO(7;7(8(3BuF_$0LDG?4xTaZtR=s(1Eh_l(cFk&1=!NjOB?uC)eK>X6Ie0J-q0&SK>D(W~yp+ zC$Q>)BnOe@{#Lo@?CHri^GGE-&nwzTKtz$y$kPSiJf^$AQ`IdnVn2gxyRHI?0}LnUBxk*NVs!H=)h%vBG9mH@~7F5y7D6LVa!yE#_7W( z$ZRYVNelp09LF~ir`klrO7G~R>jb2N-KUu}>e7YVwpZA@!cFs1g&J3C0`JN9A5#RZ4k(*}w@M_knRp92*C2CGSCC+vBN*Q*mqUM|ggp zVVn8JVssDQB`1R}j2UCZ!F zQ_azdx7Lqt43`#E#cy^L%&83;=YF}JKQrQP; zl89o_2-xKNDP(Z%smYjj-F{xg>;aEl*fITh@w1z<5uT@?*o^9?_ifC|ceXOv!ri-< z4XXvP2@!B7u#Gkh%uonLs8=5E^IvSD;df2T<=XZoo*7k(m)+z{%R4SAV@`)dfx?Ev zB4>b4wSp(JHx=<^c_5cMM}glVBq8NpuM9#qDyGAHlgOFM@k@=tL|P?|5j_A7KuhLY zKufb%BVY1&7f<|(&wWAOzdRk$WNs-bJcUQuYm&vqZ)WOa&k##ih>ZB&m(^Q^JEsAd zgB7q1$BWY#U`#k~ixRIS#;GVjKdv{Rp@_%rPUkCa=1Q7RpMDc? z6gQgJEoE~iAF(SNXvrswPibG%6he8v??<9Vme%rCm8NKjVy~Hu%=^yqePb-NrmPWe zumk!Tlcwz7fQ3Szd#7t0n;8!{rn``{y#-f0XwnSaPsR+JpG+}E%x&r?d}+EZWSI1J zQGjP7k@Ns>%dCoNOeLzvj7D^W*^8eG32x=~+Qw za2mA1^QsdEd=X;L#4?;x@-HhsHypi`s&C|Zc{R$ygr#w{`WqkpMqrEUy>+<+F{XJR zdnooPe^aFi(v5e1(p0~Sz*x?a?%IneNfK<9vj z&IvmDd6+`cTg`l?DPne`n2^(b{dAkt%)pl!z-Db3d20+3rUJiNO11R*(5Q&GpDMzQ zbW(eO&i1xE)q0kR(_Y{Y>)Dbxy~OQzd&B)kD(3AAfbZ1xAkdq76OJ={qa|0BDdu}y zZnL3`oFkTPP1}5)IjvXTf^61;96e{fd`*@5!ZlRc_JcOergQu7CH81pe$x?)ff_qj zz0mENPc(x(kr$nO%F0uLKn|0(+%3Lw*wnAP0qCs0dZn8#M|wYQjFgSJlNP*ww0lRR z;zdLdwft9UEE3Ow{#hj_w2Qrg)HuIyjTw(!HG6XKB1yDr%_eh0OE9%6r zJnF!1^QXHb&d`p9hIAEow~#lhWDQ2jE0+GG=Tg!=p89JSQ4FxB@ZNFu)-A3{*8Wzr zryA}!X%rsH?Bkh@G!!LJEceU6EzzA3HvPkhojGvc$y~z4H_u7kwP@gm{_m)_fn{qv zJuwh&z{9FT>SQWrv;x}|A(2#9&DN9EtI1n+EHZ>i7lDm_pMuj>cVR)XU|Pg*Sf#&| z3eMZrN7CPR-(QA7^YMtcVrhw-Ut^qWmHj>beUE!}ez?NLS_RR#gm*tdLve>=zCZa4 zXzgfVgV}@?@uBz|xcc&OO(}9nTgwe1I8Ft_nQi;+?E-2_bd1e9PlrjQ!4?So(iG%i zHMZfsMKRrJWLGbINIk3N`oj+kGM9CUwR-}UUbr$6SV;r+JL>i}89RX+D*zu9E=iow#5wbP$n_m?^+AS9c7RX3|PbxFX+0QyLb{czk0YD&h0z*XuG%(>x1-a%;|tx=-*hW_qJ{BVe)Wd$PXMtl1Hb7YRPyaaK`Do43UW!GR@ydnOP`h(?M zl^?~!B*m)bVc*Bl-}2`L&p0w~c-=*u+XN2>aqqiRpT^t8n(BI9zoeSug#3A&{Jmw8 zeM;9Z@)vXd(W${yfjMox%est4b*fzY;g7~?oZR6)L_W>_oA}T#Ut_N&?O3J5o6=*f zH<3iMLHo7Ltj&Hn?^)#c>l0+7KCFJjt0~W{KKi*n)s_n2f#?`-TwJ=!gzRN1Y2aIz zT$5;*wM^8~mw%#unZ}6mlfFY;{80{ob+f4otAm>o=pJKZwQ#G{GAZ&@ zPVKh7;+W09sn`3BA)ossvhp}>YM>Pc9}>&D+X6NlJcP~7Mm)JBH+FpgGa2vCE~MUk z_5;T68mdvW{X&AO2eLmTnCM#|=0_9g!4Ip0{Zm(^vecN;a{99~1P)wAs`%N{tA@$2 zlz`-Ze9Lt#qw(ydYMx_u<>p+}sa$AEct;xM&=@I5emqUGF-Gc6U%jLD)Y;_$PJTm| zTc!1&P*-$u(tc3pP%E2|nUM*VLX`sbo~>9>oFX+=Dv*=M*Mt(Dsv>-nkhy`fev@uq zEb3F^JM&N7IF+5JUR9qt4P#^SJpx$Ug1j$AJ5z$Mj%X+D9c1=|rH$kuM<%?jao}r0 zSRw?v*f2_*4)yPgHz;=(u1N4XP{ZqgWxME7S<&w)y@2f6+6?N~l=T6iGX%nCXkn&bfktl+BQReE)#kU@cVGE# zvrRsj!(G3K>e-zg!@YW{-NVe4=XqdpyjhJRdGwUHjhR>v`yZf01+OHtSo~ti!F@%m z`fc^M(z=PaiKy$u9;~)SQ@NP7WDUynt7#C?-arsy5_|WggNhT}gQE^mE{A_7P zTZnNhEL8ZhMd0(B`dK8M&JmHe>ler{@yK4l;urab2MfRcaL;lv?Lq22=sa$GrktAk zwKC=Q@Sq^k^7g6CbxB4dyPAcD6bAA5gA;Xf-s2}4x{m5bbJJyk;>Rt8@K8yFpfn3- zD%aL}Q769su;7p%16p}1V{vXJ{ghypEn(5Ru;6F znDh@_y*<>R=zysimyV5WXY_Z;>95qBvkPu@eVI*MB>%n_5elu*WbGPVsfrVuB^7A= zQ4J~>n;%}b&C>>g4r?Z)10cK+31)`r^A9>$4Z*{YjjmZLZUweRpLD7o=*%>+WhxP& z)_NPT@?O8&8Qevkxut*)d{V&UBAPsId@uN7%&`xdrS{DmI&zpp{XKej;8Xky>%2qw zz6+?j%U9za0`s2Q9HPXsyKn1`!I5{|7pD>V9qLH~2K*hH@s5`VeNRRct}%eTUtc`K zr1$wF)99!fYRSfq`Lm)FZY)`sGvuVJ6-S2c)_^5g1*Pvn{d6| zpN~)Z1B4l1Y!wuXnrSKr>>WsO7Tf zvYM6+1!;G>fVh_kcw^WNaYFw)pI%zx^JWe4ST_|G@H!Lw@-eN=rSp8tsT!{WQJRR& z#ACZkyPEarhJ3g0bKNsZ*RaVmSX~a@E~!`?v_v<~Zn!_qE~3OHKqOnEvQPVqH_)KhmHb%Dpn4P_DherRC;CTCpqy33>Ma8yL@#U)h((#wN_;_xlkF@%@ml(3?q|pB1 zd_`Zu*jDh?EY){qvj|b49tQ=dxX^;KQp;M-YrPXIYJ9R$$*O*Ip7_^nT-?%OSxY#rigy*GR$->wS);(9nS#cYgf zOk3~N>FbT^1+GB;RUh4Z+0`4)+Eo=Q67Q7;*;Lb!bPd098vQCBBpm!l}lM-@{=4$xBVx? zy2Zsqb-k_SR^5dG-kf?-=UYtE; z0OR{nA2dD__}5+3vwUT5G`~PZbKqq*u7OlF&$*L&YVUKj)5J-C@YC3CG)=dC?lUBr zlos`PpI=XMz_<&4a4!k)Db`Ev5qe46wR`p|NOG%%JnJF9)Hc}?C!hht4Fy$wfcmNd z?7h>>lRO+r8qD)7bF}#tsSe#Ct&7LoA1`nUNhA;}NL={n&L?sp8^e;sjv-T+!9jT6 zB4AHpcXW4o-rW<{z(e{jY2T^9Zee)tH1RIoO1);3xdj=z+_?qa!e#?~j<`dx24dSS zA*mv9P}<~tEQNNjq+^+ja@891`NlDybkVJAz+qR-f4xmQ7=~hznh!4Wj@&?5!Wh&u zzU&}pvPHUv>vh>Md8S{kv(m6HUys#V|H1C-C->%C;$!I&D$GB48xK}g>KOaG2%6(s zt)qhC-2La)+2fBpuL{l`7pgw165mn3Cc8Z9C>uE@-*5^owb_*{ZY*mFt+u?9uu`;n zr2-J=bDpGKQR}MD6eWmlI0BES6g2%ke4*s}gFhGS>-k=KvB&MUeqk*#cL-Y@-Ps>c z();m7w$3!#7(Y8vh2_kj+uo@PuF7AzVxsDjlRJz)+J6~r-|;vfFSGiBN@hUa3Uf?C z=GbhG{yV1)m5=0)J>voyH2BH(FEhd)hX|(y5KVE_I;aKs>_$j0W;iTQ|@li6By8JVe znAC@`M-}8yE%)?V!G7UsJ)EuWDW%^jzgM2d7qp-8iv2wvqMPuZq(}eri}(+;xs~9J zRf%G<4HccSADjoD=5>lmrVPzEcUnHC8LjvpwAhG8;ImFlKQ``72m3Tfp-!@mZJL#EOId(8#Ig)?iJb$SbaljA=4a znPP6XPb5VP5UIxQQzZ`>0G6wR!qV9^8L{;>@W*9Je7#TK=M*Lkr1R~FC0SFeyTZoJ zPG!BG=g<)Ytbqhu4=F<|f_RDopgcSn{~Gmiz*RBlot81x9Hr+!=%@IYxKjFef0Q4I zLr@T4|DX>uZ7-ufHNY^Qi;L;*?fM@uUMWNC2Ofw;J~&2FeoMsY?cg*w^fO@huq|bl z2my&bjL{rOc=5y3`<9O*;dQcJ?b!-WD5W1o#@Bv;2t^ zH6NYki>bKSSF{Pc(_c@@@n#=i^L^7}4)bJh5D@-M^U|5@9x72*t#vC&hyfj=7|Du` zjdBb;P)Ksvj$D7lRK7An-*7rKH5eWz6SkXo^fJatatGESE9@1pdT_r^O(9Fn%uu2krzi*T`Gf6y@4EYCx?g9t8Kfi&@xdG)C%1?#8wx@h@Br;I z+ncdEihER18AfThyS=eDBvC!;M}nkiS#v1}tFPgo+=L9YR+;9x=jdC@_+jVo(3Ta+ zR+~tDZgdZA*NwS*C_RpkbU*y1PVPD+D*}0=vLFa`1{iIN?2cvt0{hHbT2B@)v;ssv z)5e$+y|5L1qGTD#9_5hxiJe{b?dp9_W%IoP(nFjf4Fjs)Dom=vhv^DirI|I8X7}=y z)(9nfi?Wvixns{e+aY;nB%hdcfCPw3iZiPGIINFyP|QvH#2$)LO;>X zTF03=G`qH}GkJ!#S>h9@NLqd4k!28XPCrd3Zz<-y#5SaYcP;vYO&8G*>WRLaH1l%|_v=3C)1PE2C(1r9mxHxhAkPXNOqxnz$f{ zqR-VVbP?GJ7f*<5)1=E0W%v7_OK8sm(d>XvcE7TO1p?8m)thtPz*!54vMr@AGH}r* zf4FR*K)UnMh1^{B$$O1FuA;Fug%2%nxN01aa#BTg>>ak7PmdJy-Hw$NNQ2Kjtb5>v zKa)u~qrf0#eTTn0%V#H~XW5N8_BWP|FruAfhI=^c4pA5{ttkZ(5_@yA?k6h!rR%Xw zCNsc^0Lp+MZOp${2gXE5)@QGfUTz~{nQie}sCLS*H>YnyQ!w!-NK|QGmQJ{8s$pnT zX}9F4)RS}cQk-clqsoK-U{OV1e;+7|Es(XfbYHIII@sH-N0~XeceYQp26|I%*&6xT zLWct=Rp2*=8b<^k$&KYR#8D1To-FU1BIc+-vT@)MH^*lgd{vpCQ)OVXmaPe(|!eSl7r=|7VeQ?L)p zwAk{{Q9|ik^PY`!l*|zGaSiFoLTaydlwI%EOa%2ihSD;L2ZFVyhWXyfr)<9%-H8E=leRl^LWwwMiSAK4a zVXP|cW>NGV%~$t}J*h zcj{g12L!Q>gUM=vxOPSaIz^;yw*2Xp36VNi=|<%o=JMm8L9)5crdoG~G#m_<9exnr zbUI5kV!Koz9lNh|^9)LaLDKB=6GA=txT)rBYOizfa43iNwOJ9 zc7jllJBQDhDPfY?N|fPtPjf(~wXpr*OQYT|FSVAl;P0C!9O-gF+JoLcE7~Ec3`EMp zn93N5Z!3IDyV=LPZr1TzaeNve4o17QOk{qq2t%0_Rx4yHwvZSip~)#V1($xH8ZV{U ziEn$ze@9a%I?(yZS2MhJg-PM2dI$vSrvt)Pi_IQ4;GsnbQp}F|b~ixYS2_)jI@|0c z2eV#}uYRHqv)HkNn!@>6$oN>A29yV%y&B5PB(GxDNxHl0&%_k{9} z%I$FjPdiOh;2>ZmyXik<)T?bn)a+p99^B+}L(F4=qfr1=c>?$NcS=Pg_CQv`W|ENF znP>6q6V!h~oJxDil1g8J^G=RN{De;8kwNB_Pt^C<%}GA6*w=?3N$>2|&DcA+zbYRN zQGA^gp~13W=^`o-trIuYZ10wnEC1kV(sWJ~Q^iE`5Xd~j9rc#OblrwWCqdz4MW1dzI0&026co!)LVFT7~sM#({F~E{{C~a>zP8F3)Hb=Pj0g;U*Y1f(qNkgwpn5E}I(%Pu(F57FLV2EQmzetr3(DIe+V$<2kZqLU>jm)5KbnrQc14n#(I(Ai(wkbT7kzM*`v(v z=4$`o6p_cit_so&F9Ec0O+E{xXJ5tripRCeil(kQ#DK(&@JC7(MBHPxTPY$+y9`3& z1wTQ0Bz(FGpjJCYCg5Tiq1J8(n@m_>RF9^Rnj2GTTaw3{1_tPh*wtw6u zw;l@GX!QN~VWam)tF6QVkl9IK+iG5=tHKCA!3KIMw{r_j^CWC3UkV;d3tq@AI!im7 z!!b3Om#7nXe6{>b1g-*bu{;0)(m^yE$+8XN?W_U^K~o(Ou_x(Fl+*A%BZ}@Gpgx z3?K}OT89rr=YIG2Kkeb4eoWla$HEX!0G1ebL@OWvBgDQ3cNa|IipD|8$2@Pi?%NAN z;JD578}4A#2V#QHLM}UMw4(IRD=R4!?Pu z&E%r>V+tpEQ?yEc3roay^-hLPSUWdYH)~|4Il4-V`TOrVwp|@Y@C~$XQ+0y2Aq z*Sd7?KSv@U(EpqTIhWJ_*F!LRyi)_eSdp{((m^t(`YlSM`fc5@-ygVGg)bg|t8Lm? zycQQe?3qHuKM)b+#EXDGi$}z1@`fiR7;DvgjsF1V?y~izrJK;m%N-L%63)k_ul2?E zSRPN$5b?Du$ZotG+_-UeZs=))yC26EXIj&_dP)8OQtcXrQ(Mo=p+LRgwG%b@!(cM`OtFQY6o2>OztY9e8F7#k zA&>SQ_^sK%FACs$a#3={{w372fKQ;vlXmf(fA0bLHEBPRd-cxClG;EuR?%|*(TpB| zfbfQ&QU8B+AsTRA1Nd23=O>G}fWa|-Xv75$F#H~mBFJ7!w~)mD&#V8BuX>SUfhPq) zk6N<0POt!9ZYevz)yW;^^vsfuX!BGBFrx?ppt6O@#1E#`lP$Joc&lwLG>^Gd{t!>f z55GkVb265h0HCG}fbb4#cjrI0(W4M7;7h;6;6DopYH3@3t!M21Ss*eHL*TGqTzdFN zwhVx5{HH6Ji~r9}lioXxz!BIMHI_T>k?|lO4o0b(gHfM@HqVc( zoshI_SoRx{Lk;k>CNcupv4T&!uWhteCDfTBC(tq8@TnkNe36DJX#Ca9-Mt>ZbH%X+ zFx4y}%lE$r9P5D=JE5l0{0o|>0Z%31nXdV_c{vcosTonsxf*Mr18_p(lQM{d{T9s= zfavyJT#cyCwVvZ`aMS@O%H%KFm;z$$9&#-Y96k7b#}KeJs6Q*Ro;Tk^g3+w5e*h`j zzZKzh7)HnM90_*p9JS4#5LY`%v z>Gv}=d&CMx^PiXhvv&W(E02h(kCOlk-(U%yK@NrG+u0lsvMgy7_^ytMd4bDQze(>^ zhQ7bDg=lcYlJl#yd=hlNKL0-ValX8DV0qn?O#U99#Rt+rapk(~-|{XH#+5ilx^w9; z0w?kMo`o9SIxklMM$3BY9mTnDA}v{#m>uCAnk6pj*z`QT(-CX5oLT& zlIw4I9GKMqjjz69qDun)&cw#q-vapm(KMh=FU>YSM4({?+Gl@eLrPpuEMMfA=YInT C?4OAs lawmakers grapple with the serious issue of child exploitation online, + some proposed solutions would fuel the very problem they aim to solve.

\ No newline at end of file